Taught by
Stephen Armstrong
Taught by
Stephen ArmstrongThe opening verses of the 23rd Psalm read:
The first half of John’s 6th chapter is the apostle’s case for Jesus as the Good Shepherd
Jesus is our shepherd who cares for our needs
And Jesus is our comforter in times of distress
The events of this chapter are set a full year after the events of chapter 5
We’re within one year of Jesus’ crucifixion
This corresponds to the late Galilean period of Jesus’ earthly ministry
That period dominates the narratives in the other three Gospels
But John devotes only chapters 6 and 7 to this period of Jesus‘ ministry
So let’s see did John wanted to emphasize about this important period of Jesus’ life
John opens by saying “after these things...”
John doesn’t mean immediately after the events of chapter 5
At the beginning of chapter 5, Jesus traveled to Jerusalem for the Passover feast
Now in 6:4 John mentions an upcoming Passover feast, which means a separate Passover event
So a whole year has passed between chapters 5 & 6
John skipped over the many events that took place in that intervening year in the Galilee
Probably because the other writers covered those things in detail
Still John did chose to include the following account of the feeding of the 5,000 and the disciples’ subsequent sailing back to Capernaum
In fact, this is the only miracle recorded in all four Gospels
Clearly, this moment is important
And John had something to add to the other writers’ accounts of these events
So we’ll make some comparisons between his account and the other Gospels as we move along
According to Mark’s account, Jesus travels from His home area near Capernaum on the Northwestern coast of the Sea of the Galilee to Bethsaida again
John simply says they went to the “other side” of the Galilee
Jesus sails about 3 miles (4.5 km), cutting across the northern tip of the sea
Prevailing winds in that area blow from West to East
So assuming they were sailing with the wind, it would have taken about an hour or two to make that journey
The place Jesus lands is a relatively remote place, sparsely inhabited
The disciples must have wondered why Jesus chose to travel into such a remote area
In v.2, we’re told a large crowd follows Jesus as He makes this journey because they seek more of Jesus’ healing ministry
We learn later in this chapter that they traveled by foot walking around the northern tip of the Galilee
In this case, the journey by foot is only a slightly longer than sailing, maybe about 4 miles of walking
An adult walks about 3 mph
So they probably arrived in Bethsaida only slightly later than Jesus
Jesus takes advantage of this head start to retreat with His disciples into the nearby mountains about a kilometer away
At this point John mentions that the Passover of the Jews was near
Consider the details in this story that John has provided already
Jesus crosses a body of water
A large crowd of needy people are following Him
He leads them to a wilderness with no apparent way to sustain them
And then Jesus retreats up the side of mountain leaving the people below
And all these things are happening in conjunction with the time of Passover, which is a memorial of Israel’s exodus out of Egypt?
Do these details ring any bells yet?
Right away we notice that John is constructing his narrative to draw our minds back to the story of Moses leading Israel out of Egypt
There is something about this account that ties back to the Exodus
Obviously, we know that Jesus fulfills the Passover as the Lamb of God sacrificed for the sins of the world
John has already made that connection for us through the words of John the Baptist
And later in the Passion of Christ, we see Jesus completing the picture in His death on the cross
But now John is working to really bring Jesus’ connection to the Exodus account into clear focus
In fact, John has already been at work in a previous chapter making this same connection, though it was subtle
Remember, after the first Passover and the resulting Exodus, the Israelites required water and food to survive in the desert
The Lord provided them water from a rock
And we know from 1Corinthians 10 that Paul says the rock was a picture of Christ
So in chapter 4, John showed us how Jesus fulfilled that picture when He told the Samaritan woman that He was he source of living water
Jesus is the Rock that gives us the water that leads us to thirst no more
And now one year later, the Passover has come again and this time Jesus will fulfill yet another picture from that most important of Jewish experiences
So as Jesus stands on the mountain, He lifts up His eyes and sees the crowd gathering at the base of the mountain waiting for Jesus to descend
He turns to one of the disciples, Philip, and asks him what should be done to feed so many people
The question is relevant, because the place was remote and the people were numerous
Jesus is telling the disciples to assume responsibility for them
Since the people have evidently followed Jesus without giving much thought to how they will eat
I like to imagine that as Jesus asked Philip the question, Jesus’ eyes glanced upward, toward the sky
Offering Philip a hint for how to answer the question
Hoping Philip’s memory of the Exodus story might kick in at this moment and he might remember how God supplied food for His people
In v.6, John makes sure we understand His question was just a test, since Jesus already had a plan
What was the test?
I think the test was whether the disciples were recognizing the picture of the Exodus that Jesus was carefully orchestrating around them
Did they realize they were re-enacting that moment, only with Jesus playing the part of Charlton Heston?
Would they put 2 and 2 together and realize that God was capable of solving this problem in His power?
Most importantly, would they understand that Jesus is the Lord Who fed the people manna the first time, and He was prepared to do it again?
The test emphasized Jesus’ identity
Just as with the woman at the well, the question is, “Who is Jesus?”
If you know Jesus is Lord and if you recognize the picture of the Exodus, then you would suggest that Jesus provide bread for the people
But that was a bridge too far for the disciples, and Philip missed the whole point of the question
Philip responds with a sense of hopelessness and defeat
He says not even 200 denari would be enough money to buy even a little food for everyone
His statement gives us an indication of how many people were assembled below
200 denari represents about 8 months salary for a working man
In present day U.S. standards, that might be around $40,000
Though that’s an enormous sum of money, it still wasn’t enough to even give the crowd even a little food each
Philip makes a matter-of-fact assessment of the situation and reports his findings
There is no spiritual dimension to his answer
He doesn’t consider supernatural possibilities
He’s thinking only of what men are capable of doing to solve a problem of this magnitude
And since the disciples lack the capability, he reasons the situation is hopeless
Matthew’s Gospel adds that the disciples went a step further at this point and recommended that Jesus send the people away since they had no solution
This is exactly the way the Israelites were thinking when they sized up their own situation in the desert
They told Moses that they expected to starve in the desert
And in their case, they blamed their predicament on God’s incompetence
The people knew the Lord had lead them into the desert in miraculous ways
Yet they hadn’t considered the possibility that this same God could feed them supernaturally in the desert
God had a plan to free 2 million slaves from Egypt, but somehow He hadn’t foreseen the need to feed them in the wilderness
So they assumed they would die of starvation
Here we see the same scenario developing with Jesus’ disciples playing the part of the Israelites
Philip can’t see a solution because he’s discounting Jesus’ potential to perform a miracle
He’s assuming the only way food will appear for this crowd is if someone orders takeout
So he failed the test, a test of whether he understood Jesus’ identity
Philip didn’t recognize Jesus to be the same Lord who fed Israel in the desert
So Jesus moves ahead with a supernatural solution as God intended
The enterprising disciple Andrew offers a potential solution
He spies an a young boy moving around the crowd with some small fish and barley loaves
The word “lad” in Greek literally means “little male child”, so we’re probably talking about a boy of perhaps 6 or 7 years old
And the Greek word for fish is the word for a very small fish, probably something like anchovies intended to be eaten as a relish with the bread
He may have been the child of a family in the crowd, and he sees an opportunity to peddle his goods
Why did Andrew even think to propose this child’s basket of goods as a solution to the problem?
Philip had just said that $40,000 worth of food wouldn’t be enough to feed these people
But then Andrew proposes this idea?
What was he thinking?
At this point in the story, most of us probably run past this detail so we can focus on what comes next
We remember Jesus turned this meager meal in a miraculous provision, but why did the apostles even think to suggest this source to Jesus?
Andrew’s suggestion is so pathetic, it seems almost nonsensical that he even raised the option in the conversation
Did he think Jesus could do something miraculous with these items?
Given the way Andrew finishes his sentence, I don’t think so
In fact, it sounds like he realized a little too late that his idea was no help at all
Still, Andrew’s contribution to the story becomes a significant detail in the story and marks a significant departure in this story from the parallels to the Exodus
In the desert situation, the Lord delivered food to Israel literally from Heaven
The manna fell from above
The Lord didn’t start with something on Earth, no matter how meager
In the Exodus account, the Lord brought a provision down from Heaven supernaturally
Obviously, Jesus will perform an equally impressive miracle this time, but it’s significant that He chooses to multiply something on Earth
In this situation, nothing new is going to come down from Heaven
This time He begins with something very meager, barely noticeable, and hardly suitable
A solution proposed by a disciple
Something that was insignificant in the eyes of men,
Hardly sufficient to solve such a pressing problem
Clearly, we should understand why the Lord has changed the program this time around
This departure from the story of Exodus is an important detail in the retelling of manna
The purpose of this departure will become clear in the second half of the chapter, as Jesus discusses the meaning of these things with the crowd
So we’ll wait until then to discover it for ourselves
Though perhaps some of you see it already too
We should also note in passing that there are a total of seven food items in the boy’s basket, which is a number that catches our attention obviously
Seven is a number meaning the total or complete or fulfilled number of something
Today, we would say “100%” to mean the total of something
The Bible uses the number “7” to mean the same thing
So, something is being completed or fulfilled in this moment
That’s something we also want to understand as we go forward
Then Jesus gives instructions to the disciples
The details are probably familiar
First, Jesus instructs the people to sit in the grass
In Mark’s Gospel we’re told they sit in groups of hundreds and fifties, which simply means into small, manageable groups
We can easily imagine practical purposes in why Jesus asked them to sit down
If hungry people see food coming their way, they tend to rush toward it to make sure they get a share
Making them sit ensures orderliness and also imparts confidence that there is a plan to ensure everyone is fed
But those practical reasons are not the main reason Jesus seats them down in grass
The main purpose relates back to Psalm 23
The Shepherd is the One Who causes His sheep to lie down in green pastures
The Shepherd cares for His sheep and makes sure they receive their rations
Sheep don’t have the ability to find their own green pastures
They are famously stupid animals
They move about in the field with their eyes down following what’s in front of their faces, even to the point of stumbling into danger
So they depend on a Shepherd to lead them
So Jesus’ instructions were part of testifying that He is the Shepherd of Psalm 23, the One who cares for us because we can’t do it for ourselves
This is true for every member of Jesus’ flock
Even when we think we’re providing for ourselves in our daily occupation or through our savings, we’re only fooling ourselves
By that thinking, we’re at risk of overlooking the Lord’s provision and presence in our life
Because everything we have comes from the Lord
The fact that our daily provision arrives by way of a weekly paycheck...
Or in a 1099...
Or through our stored up savings...
Doesn’t mean our security is any less the result of God’s ongoing provision of grace
At any moment, those things could (and often do) disappear
And when they do, we’ll finally recognize that we never had security because of those things
Our security comes from the Shepherds willingness to care for His sheep
By causing us to lie down in green pastures when we need them
At this point, John gives us the head count of men, numbering them at about 5,000
The overall number is not significant (apart from the occurrence of the number “5,” which is the number of grace), but it reinforces the size of the problem facing the disciples
5,000 men means 5,000 families
5,000 families means a lot of people
Which would explain why $40,000 wasn’t enough to give everyone even a little food
There could have been as many as 15K-30K people at the base of that mountain!
Considering that this scene takes place near the end of Jesus’ years working in the Galilee, it’s entirely likely He has amassed a very a large following by this point
It would also explain why the Pharisees viewed Jesus as a serious threat to their power and authority
Anyone who is followed by a loyal crowd of 20K people has real power
Next, Jesus gives thanks for the food and the miracle that’s about to follow, then He begins to break the bread and divide the fish out
John says Jesus distributed the food to the people seated, but Mark’s Gospel clarifies that Jesus distributed the food through the hands of the disciples
Jesus handed the food to each disciple who then carried it down to the people in a basket
Therefore, each disciple returned to Jesus many times to refill their baskets
And as this process continued, the groups of people ate their fill, no one was left wanting
You have to wonder what was going through the minds of the disciples as they moved up and down the mountain filling their baskets
They knew Jesus started with only a little food
But now they find their their baskets filled time and time again
There is no conversation among the disciples recorded by any of the Gospels
So I assume the disciples were speechless, unable to muster words
Though I assume they probably exchanged a few glances with each other as they passed back and forth on the mountain
After the crowd had been fed (which must have taken several hours), Jesus ordered the disciples to collect the excess food from the people
Don’t overlook that the disciples were required to collect the food from the people
The Lord could have simply multiplied more food for each disciple
Instead, the disciples’ food had already been handed out to the people below
The Lord had literally given away the disciples’ food, so that now the disciples had to go back and retrieve it from the people
So how do we imagine the disciples went about collecting that food?
Obviously, they had to petition the people for it
The people would have likely wanted to keep it for themselves
So the disciples walked among the groups of people calling for all excess food to be collected and placed in the disciples’ baskets
The excess materialized as Jesus said, because the Lord had ensured that there was more provided to the people than they needed
That excess was a reflection of the Lord’s abundant goodness
But it was also a provision intended to meet the needs of those disciples who had just worked to serve the people
Notice that the amount collected was exactly twelve baskets, reflecting the 12 apostles who had served the people
What was Jesus trying to teach us by the way He constructed this process of feeding the people and providing for the disciples?
First, Jesus often begins His greatest works among His people with meager beginnings
When Jesus turned to Philip, it was Philip’s opportunity to suggest something great
Instead, Philip gave up on the situation because no solution was readily visible
Faith isn’t faith if relies only on what can be seen, as Paul taught
Sincere, active faith requires a willingness to act in hopeful expectation
Andrew was a step closer to faith because at least he suggested a solution that depended on faith in God’s ability to multiply
But just as quickly, he retreated from faith by abandoning the possibility
What would have happened if someone had suggested to Jesus that they hand out the boy’s food expecting the Lord to make it sufficient to meet the need?
I believe the situation would have turned out exactly the same
And that’s the point
Jesus’ opening question was an opportunity for these men to participate in a miraculous work of God that He was already planning to accomplish
It was a work the Lord was prepared to perform with or without their participation
But by offering them the chance to believe in it before they saw it, they could be blessed in having their faith strengthened
There is a real spiritual blessing for the believer when they act in faith, as Jesus told Thomas
So the first lesson is those who serve the Lord must step out with faith expecting the Lord is prepared to work through meager beginnings
Don’t let meager beginnings hold you back from meeting needs and expecting miracles
Secondly, the Lord’s servant can’t stray far from the Master in our service
As many Bible commentaries have observed, Jesus caused the disciples to return to Him repeatedly as they went about the business of serving the people
Each disciple’s success depended on continually returning to the Lord to fill a basket
If they returned, they had something to offer the people
If they didn’t come back, they soon would have nothing
And they would be useless
The picture couldn’t be clearer: we must abide in Christ if we are to serve in His power
The disciples couldn’t make the food multiply on their own
They didn’t possess magic baskets
They were simply waiters
On the other hand, their role wasn’t irrelevant
Jesus designed the miracle so that it depended on the disciples delivering the food to the people
At first, the people were largely unaware of what was happening up on the mountain
They just knew that the disciples were bringing them a meal
No one ministers to God’s people by virtue of brilliance or training or experience or sheer force of our personality...
Successful servants of God only deliver what Jesus provides for His flock
What He gives us tends to run out pretty quick
So we have to return time and time again
Return to His word
Return to Him in prayer
Return to Him in repentance and humility
If we do that, we can be useful to Him and become part of making amazing things happen
Thirdly, from our limited perspective, the works we’re called to join rarely appear miraculous or even very important, but God can accomplish much through us
Consider that these disciples probably never witnessed the moment when Jesus multiplied the bread or fish
More likely, it seems they simply came back to Jesus to find more food ready to load into their baskets
Obviously, they knew something special was happening, but in the moment, their job was nothing more than picking up food and delivering it
Often, that’s what it’s like to serve God from our perspective
We’re just delivering fish
We volunteer for a duty in the church
We participate in a service project
We host someone in our home
We offer a prayer request
We write a check to a missionary
But as we do what the Lord asks us to do, we become part of a larger work that leads to miraculous outcomes by God’s power and orchestration
Sometimes, the Lord is willing to grant us peek into the supernatural outcomes that result from our work
Most times, we never see it
But eventually, when we enter into our glory, we will learn all the works of God and how we participated in those things by faith
Finally, those who serve the Lord should expect that their hard work will be met by an adequate provision from the Lord
But that provision doesn’t materialize out of think air
It comes as a consequence of serving God’s people diligently
I imagine the disciples were exhausted after going up and down the mountain so many times over several hours
Perhaps they wondered when it would be their turn to eat or even if there would be enough left for them
But in the end, the Lord took care of them
A servant of God should expect to receive God’s provision as a consequence of working hard to serve God’s people
And that provision will be supplied from the hands of those whom he serves
The Lord supplies His people with an excess intended to meet the needs of the Lord’s servants
And then the Lord calls upon His servants to seek for that provision from among the people so that they may be blessed by giving back
And God’s people must be willing to relinquish the excess to those who deserve it
But the servant’s provision is to be no more luxurious than that given to God’s people
In this case, the disciples received the same provision that the people received from the Lord
Some fish and bread
If Jesus had been handing out steak and lobster, then the disciples might have expected to receive the same
And if the Lord had chosen to provide rice and beans, then the Lord’s servant couldn’t expect something better
In all cases, the servant should be allowed to share in that provision
But always remembering that if we have food and covering, we should be content Paul says
Sooner or later, the crowd realizes the magnitude of the miracle that has taken place, and perhaps they also recognize the connection to the Exodus story
Notice that people declare this miracle was a sign to them
Calling something a sign means they believed God was revealing something to them through these events
They were correct, but they misunderstood the meaning of the sign
They said that Jesus was the Prophet who has come into the world
They were referring to the prophet Moses said would come to Israel one day in the future
The prophet Moses was describing was the Messiah, Jesus
So the people were correct when they recognize Jesus as the fulfillment of Moses’ promise
But then they go in the wrong direction
They conclude that the Prophet would conquer Israel’s political enemy, Rome, and lead Israel into political freedom just as Moses did against Egypt
So they call for Jesus to be taken to Jerusalem and install Him as their new political leader
Notice John says they want to take Jesus by force
It’s unclear if John means they are preparing to force Jesus to go to Jerusalem
Or perhaps John means they are calling for people to join Jesus in forcing the Romans out of Israel
Either way, they have exactly the wrong idea of why Jesus came to Israel
Yes, Jesus is the prophet Moses promised
But Jesus came for heavenly, eternal purposes, not earthly, temporal purposes
To properly understand the connection between Jesus‘ ministry and Moses‘ ministry, we first have to understand that pictures in scripture always form a lessor to greater relationship
Moses’ life and work was constructed by God to form a lessor version of Jesus’ ministry
From his birth to His exile in the desert to His return for Israel to His role as a mediator and so on (see our Exodus study), Moses pictured Christ
Moses set Israel free from slavery to Egypt, but Jesus sets men free from slavery to sin
Moses led Israel to the Old Covenant in stone while Jesus leads men to the New Covenant in His body
Moses’ conquered the army of Egypt, while Christ conquers the forces of Satan
So Jesus’ ministry was a greater ministry than Moses, thus making Moses a picture of Christ in lessor form
But the people didn’t see that relationship
They perceived Moses and the Prophet as working on the same level and for the same purposes
This was a consistent point of confusion among the people of Israel in Jesus’ day
They couldn’t understand how Jesus could be greater than Moses or Abraham or even Jacob, as the woman at the well remarked
Even today people continue to repeat this mistake of reducing Jesus’ ministry and teaching to only earthly outcomes
Today people will say Jesus was merely a good teacher or “spiritual leader” or moral example or even prophet
They deny Jesus as God
So they can ignore questions of death and judgment and hell that Jesus’ ministry raised
By reducing Jesus’ goals to nothing more than an earthly agenda, an unbeliever can feel comfortable in their sin
These Jews rushed to assuming an earthly purpose in Jesus’ miracles because they never considered they were in need of a spiritual solution
They heard Jesus teaching and saw His miracles
Yet they respond by declaring Jesus will conquer Rome
When Jesus saw what was developing, He retreats back up the mountain to remain inaccessible to them
Jesus wasn’t going to allow the crowd to redirect His mission toward an earthly kingdom
We could ask why didn’t Jesus give the people both?
Why didn’t He defeat Rome and bring them salvation?
Because the Kingdom couldn’t be installed until the citizens of the Kingdom have been prepared to enter into it
And those citizens are to be found by faith
I think Christians occasionally make this same mistake today
We reduce the spiritual purpose of the Church and the Gospel to achieving earthly goals and establishing earthly kingdoms
We say Jesus fed the people, so our Christian goal should be feeding the poor
Jesus healed the people, so our Christian ministry should be healing the sick
And so on...seeking to better the lives of people by addressing their physical needs
Without a doubt, the Church has a mission to show compassion for the needs of people, but the New Testament sets boundaries for that mission
First, benevolence is to be directed to the Church, first and foremost
The NT letters command the church to care for the physical needs of the saints
There is no general command in scripture for the Church to make a priority of feeding, clothing or caring for the physical needs of all humanity
Secondly, when the Church does endeavor to meet physical needs in the world, our charity must be purposeful
We are seeking opportunities to preach the Gospel
We want to show them love and gain their attention, so we can turn that moment to a discussion of heavenly things
We have sought to address an earthly need so that we can discuss their heavenly need
When the church becomes preoccupied with solving earthly needs only, without turning those contacts into Heavenly discussions, we’ve followed the mistake of these Jews following Jesus
We are trying to take Jesus by force in a direction He will not go
The ministry of the Church cannot be co-opted into a mission of charity or public works
It’s this thinking that eventually leads to “Christian” hospitals, universities, retirement homes, and other businesses
Ironically, many of these institutions eventually outlaw the preaching of the Gospel in the spirit of tolerance
The Church mission is to preach the Gospel so that souls may be saved
The body is not our focus; the soul is
Scripture quotations taken from the (NASB®) New American Standard Bible®, Copyright © 1995, 2020 by The Lockman Foundation. Used by permission. All rights reserved. www.lockman.org